What are contentful mental states? Dretske’s theory of mental content viewed in the light of robot learning and planning algorithms
نویسندگان
چکیده
One concern of philosophy of mind is how sensorimotor agents such as human infants can develop contentful mental states. This paper discusses Fred Dretske’s theory of mental content in the context of results from our work with mobile robots. We argue that Dretske’s theory, while attractive in many ways, relies on a distinction between kinds of representations that cannot be practically maintained when the subject of one’s study is robotic agents. In addition, Dretske fails to distinguish classes of representations that carry different kinds of mental content. We conclude with directions for a theory of mental content that maintains the strengths of Dretske’s theory.
منابع مشابه
What are contentful mental states? Dretske's theory of mental content viewed in the light of robot learning and planning algortihms
One concern of philosophy of mind is how sensorimotor agents such as human infants can develop contentful mental states. This paper discusses Fred Dretske’s theory of mental content in the context of results from our work with mobile robots. We argue that Dretske’s theory, while attractive in many ways, relies on a distinction between kinds of representations that cannot be practically maintain...
متن کاملPlanning Robot Motion in a 2-D Region with Unknown Obstacles
The purpose of this paper is to present several algorithms for planning the motion of a robot in a two-dimensional region having obstacles whose shapes and locations are unknown. The convergence and efficiency of the algorithms are discussed and upper bounds for the lengths of paths generated by the different algorithms are derived and compared.
متن کاملStudy of Evolutionary and Swarm Intelligent Techniques for Soccer Robot Path Planning
Finding an optimal path for a robot in a soccer field involves different parameters such as the positions of the robot, positions of the obstacles, etc. Due to simplicity and smoothness of Ferguson Spline, it has been employed for path planning between arbitrary points on the field in many research teams. In order to optimize the parameters of Ferguson Spline some evolutionary or intelligent al...
متن کاملNaturalizing Self-Consciousness
The crucial problem of self-consciousness is how to account for knowing self-reference without launching into a regress or without presupposing self-consciousness rather than accounting for it (circle). In the literature we find two bottom-up proposals for solving the traditional problem: the postulation of nonconceptual forms of self-consciousness and the postulation of a pre-reflexive form of...
متن کاملSpatial Representation and Production and Reproduction of the Mental Image: Lefebvre’s Trialectic Approach
Lefebvre's theory of space production has been very much considered. In particular, it is important to integrate it systematically into the categories of city and space as a comprehensive and comprehensible social theory. Lefebvre's theory of space production has been remarkable in recent years and has responded well to the many questions posed in the early 1970s. Lefebvre in his trialectic in ...
متن کامل